Not many contemporary plays can
lay claim to comprising a category unto themselves, but
William Finn and James Lapine's "Falsettos" comes close.
The 1992 work, with music and
lyrics by Finn and a libretto by Finn and Lapine, is a
through-sung chamber musical about the dawning of the AIDS
era, circa 1980-81, and the disease's effect upon the new,
"alternative" families formed by gay men who married women and
had children before separating and taking gay partners.
Finn and Lapine's originality
paid off, for "Falsettos" nabbed Tony Awards for Best Score
and Best Book of a Musical. In telling the tale of a gay
Jewish man and his extended family, "Falsettos" shows how
specific people and situations can, and often do, have
universal meaning.
At Costa Mesa Civic Playhouse,
that meaning comes through loud and clear, thanks to a clean,
simple and forthright staging by Kyle Myers. "Falsettos" is a
tender, funny treatment of potentially dark subjects, and
actor-director Myers and his cast prove skilled at the unique
subgenre of theater the work represents, and at expressing its
seriocomic tone.
Myers plays Marvin, whose
family includes his ex-wife, Trina (Cathy Petz), and their
adolescent son, Jason (Paul Pakler); Marvin's gay lover,
Whizzer (Christopher Diehl); Marvin's faithful shrink, Mendel
(Joaquin Nunez); and Whizzer's lesbian doctor (Janet McGregor)
and her life partner (Jennifer Bridge).
Each of these characters
struggles to find a place in a world of gay and lesbian
couples now forced to deal with the specter of AIDS. As Marvin
and Trina's lives are intertwined, as Jason finds Whizzer a
better friend than his own parents, and as Mendel and Trina
wed, a new family is born. Their lives, though, are colored
with ambiguity - even the supremely blithe Mendel is made to
deal with uncertainty.
As in opera, the characters
express affection, jealousy, rage and other complex emotions
entirely in song. The light rock-music score includes "What
More Can I Do," a tender, expressive ballad by Marvin; Trina's
bitter burlesque parody "I'm Breakin' Down"; and "Everyone
Hates His Parents," a charming number typical of the show's
thematic universality where a sympathetic Mendel counsels new
stepson Jason.
Justin Pyne's musical
direction and accompaniment are distinctly lyrical yet
smoothly unobtrusive, and many a lyric is pungent: Marvin
sings that "Love is spiteful in a million ways," while Trina
is "holding to the ground as the ground keeps shifting,"
realizing the utter truth in the seeming cliche "Life is never
what you plan."
In a cast notable for assured
vocal work, Myers and Diehl are particularly solid.
Myers shows Marvin's roiling
passions, both inner and external. As Whizzer's feelings
toward Marvin are ever-shifting, turbulence is etched on
Diehl's sensitive face. Also notable is Pakler's Jason, an
exceptionally bright boy preparing for his bar mitzvah.
Resembling a junior Bill Gates, Pakler expresses something
every teen can relate to: frustration toward his parents'
selfishness.
Finn based "Falsettos" on two
previous musicals he wrote in the late '80s - "March of the
Falsettos" and "Falsettoland" - yet the true meaning of the
show's title is left vague and undefined. Finn's lyrics,
though, and the situations his characters endure, tell all.
The song line "Who is man enough to march the March of the
Falsettos?" leaves little doubt that Finn believes it takes
true grit to own up to, and live openly with, being gay.